
Key Takeaways for Agencies
Learn the Client’s Business First
❃
Lead with Measurement That Matters
❃
Bring Relevant, Not Generic, Innovation
❃
Build Trust Through Honest Partnership
❃
Accelerate Speed and Reduce Friction
❃
Strengthen Storytelling and Internal Alignment
❃
Execute a Disciplined First 90 Days
❃
Use AI as a Practical Advantage
Financial marketers today are asking for far more than campaign support. The group describes agencies as strategic partners who must understand the business, challenge assumptions, and help prove that marketing drives measurable outcomes. This shift reflects the realities of financial services: long sales cycles, fragmented attribution, heavy compliance requirements, multiple internal stakeholders, and constant pressure to justify spend.
The panel believes agencies are no longer valued only for just creative output or media buying, alone. They are expected to bring an outside perspective, business fluency, speed, honesty, and the ability to translate marketing activity into a narrative that executives, sales teams, and decision-makers can support. In some cases, agencies act as an extension of internal teams; in others, they resemble management consultants with marketing expertise.
The strongest theme across the discussion is partnership. The group emphasizes that agencies must be easy to work with, proactive, curious, and willing to engage in hard conversations early. They also highlight the importance of helping clients navigate a data-rich but attribution-challenged environment. Agencies that stand out combine creativity with discipline and help marketers move faster, think more clearly, and communicate more effectively.
SHORT LIST EXCLUSIVE:
What Financial Marketers Want From Their Agencies
Summer 2026

Fearured Panelists

Scott Anderson
SVP, Marketing, Alger

Kasia Antczak
CMO, Head, Individual Markets Marketing, Guardian Life

Lou Cohen
Director, Digital Marketing & Demand Generation COE Leader, Americas, EY

Michael Lacorazza
Chief Marketing Officer,
US Bank

Mary Mallery
Senior Director, Industry & Account-Based Marketing, Financial, KPMG US

Meghan McCartan
Chief Marketing Officer, Composition Wealth

Laura Manley
Global Chief Marketing Officer, MetLife Investment Management

Tokes Ojo-Ade
Head, US Integrated Media Strategy, T.Rowe Price
Panel Summary Points: What Financial Marketers Want From Their Marketing
Measurement and Attribution Challenges
The group underscored that one of the most critical roles for agencies is demonstrating results. In institutional and B2B marketing, sales cycles can span several years, making attribution difficult. Agencies are expected to define meaningful measurement frameworks that align with business goals and adapt to different stakeholder expectations.
The group noted that both online and offline data must be considered, with offline data often harder to access and interpret. More importantly, agencies must help align stakeholders who may have conflicting views on what drives outcomes. Bridging data, interpretation, and internal narratives is seen as a major value driver.
Creativity and Fresh Perspective
The group highlighted that agencies should bring new thinking that internal teams may not see. Exposure to multiple clients and industries allows agencies to introduce relevant best practices and creative approaches.
At the same time, the group cautioned against generic or recycled ideas. Creativity must be tailored to the client’s specific context. Agencies add the most value when they help organizations break out of routine thinking, while staying grounded in business reality.
Business Fluency and Strategic Partnership
The group emphasized that agencies must understand the client’s business as deeply as they understand marketing. This includes distribution economics, product structures, advisor behavior, compliance constraints, and revenue drivers.
There is a strong view that agencies are increasingly expected to operate like management consultants. This includes better upfront preparation, stronger briefs, stakeholder mapping, and clear problem definition. The group repeatedly returned to a central question: what problem are we actually trying to solve?
Storytelling and Internal Alignment
The group stressed that storytelling is essential, particularly in connecting marketing activity to business outcomes. Metrics such as clicks and downloads are not sufficient unless they are translated into impact that leadership values.
The group believes agencies should help build internal narratives that earn executive support, secure budget, and align sales teams. In addition, agencies should participate in stakeholder conversations to better understand priorities and ensure alignment with business objectives.
Relationship Management and Trust
The group consistently reinforced that strong relationships are foundational. Agencies should foster open dialogue and address challenges before they escalate. Honest feedback is highly valued, especially when it challenges internal assumptions.
The group also noted that successful relationships are built through human interaction rather than cold outreach. Trust develops through consistent engagement, credibility, and shared understanding.
Operational Efficiency and Speed
The group pointed out that financial institutions often face structural barriers to speed due to compliance and process requirements. Agencies can add significant value by reducing friction across workflows, data integration, and production.
There is strong appreciation for agencies that accelerate time to insight and time to market. Even incremental efficiency gains are viewed as meaningful business contributions.
Onboarding and First 90 Days
The group agreed that early engagement sets the tone for the relationship. Agencies should clearly define expectations, avoid overpromising, and communicate transparently about constraints.
Preparation, organization, and proactive communication are critical. The group views repeated follow-ups from clients as a negative signal, while structured onboarding and experienced teams build confidence quickly.
AI and Evolving Capabilities
The group sees AI as an important but practical tool. Agencies are not expected to have complete mastery, but they should understand how AI can improve processes such as reporting, targeting, and execution.
The expectation is applied value. Agencies that use AI to enhance efficiency and insight will differentiate themselves.

Key Takeaway for Agencies
Learn the Client’s Business First
-
Build a deep understanding of distribution models, product economics, compliance, and sales dynamics.
-
Map stakeholders early and identify decision-makers, influencers, and blockers.
-
Start every engagement by clearly defining the core business problem to solve.
Lead with Measurement That Matters
-
Align on KPIs that reflect real business outcomes, not just marketing activity.
-
Develop flexible attribution frameworks that account for long sales cycles.
-
Translate performance data into clear, executive-ready narratives.
-
Show Up Prepared and Proactive
-
Bring a clear process, structured timelines, and defined deliverables from day one.
-
Anticipate client needs and stay ahead of deadlines and follow-ups.
-
Communicate constraints early and offer alternative solutions when needed.
Bring Relevant, Not Generic, Innovation
• Introduce fresh ideas informed by cross-industry experience.
• Tailor all recommendations to the client’s specific business context.
• Use curiosity and questioning to uncover insights the client may have missed.
Build Trust Through Honest Partnership
• Offer candid feedback, even when it challenges client assumptions.
• Address difficult issues early through direct and constructive dialogue.
• Invest in long-term relationship building through consistent, meaningful interaction.
Accelerate Speed and Reduce Friction
• Identify inefficiencies across data, workflows, and production processes.
• Use tools, automation, and streamlined workflows to shorten timelines.
• Focus on reducing time to insight and time to market.
Strengthen Storytelling and Internal Alignment
• Help clients articulate a clear narrative that connects marketing to revenue.
• Support internal buy-in across leadership, sales, and other stakeholders.
• Participate in key meetings to stay aligned with evolving priorities.
Execute a Disciplined First 90 Days
• Deliver a structured onboarding experience with experienced team members.
• Set realistic expectations and avoid overpromising.
• Demonstrate reliability, responsiveness, and attention to detail immediately.
Use AI as a Practical Advantage
• Apply AI to improve reporting, targeting, and campaign efficiency.
• Focus on tangible use cases rather than broad claims of capability.
• Continuously test and refine AI-driven approaches to deliver measurable value.

For More Information Regarding Gramercy Institute membership, sponsorship and future event tickets, contact

